Restaurant in Conneaut, OH
Castaways
191 items on the menu
Order direct →Ordering happens on the restaurant’s own site. Pickup and delivery options depend on the restaurant.
The menu
Prices come straight from Castaways’s own ordering site and can change. Items sold out today are left off.
Pizza 4
-
Cheese Pizza
-
$11.15
Gluten Free Pizza
-
$11.15
Cauliflower Pizza
-
$22.95
Party Sheet Pizza
Specialty Pizza 14
-
Our Famous Terry's Oriental Pizza
Our ranch sauce, broccoli, mushrooms and crispy chicken marinated in our special oriental sauce.
-
Eye Opener Pizza
Pepperoni, mushrooms, mild peppers and our homemade spicy oil sauce.
-
The Castaways Special Pizza
This is for the seafood lovers! Our alfredo sauce topped with crab cakes and parmesan cheese.
-
Dano's Special Pizza
Our famous Philly steak with a special honey mustard sauce.
-
White Veggie Pizza
Our ranch sauce, broccoli, tomato and green peppers.
-
Harbor Sunrise Pizza
Our garlic sauce, mild peppers and tomatoes.
-
Hawaiian Pizza
-
Supreme Pizza
sausage, onions, and green peppers.
-
BBQ Ckn Pizza
Our ranch sauce, crispy chicken tossed in our signature BBQ or Buffalo sauce and topped with cheddar cheese.
-
Buffalo Ckn Pizza
Our ranch sauce, crispy chicken tossed in our signature BBQ or Buffalo sauce and topped with cheddar cheese.
-
Taco Pizza
Our taco sauce, cheddar cheese, seasoned ground beef, onion, black olives then topped with fresh lettuce and tomatoes. Served with sour cream and taco sauce.
-
Meatlovers Pizza
Loaded with pepperoni, bacon, sausage, ham and our homemade sliced meatballs.
-
Ckn Broccoli Ranch Pizza
Our ranch sauce, crispy chicken, broccoli and cheddar.
-
Pickle Pizza
Our ranch base loaded with dill pickle slices.
Wings 2
-
Traditional Wings
-
Boneless Wings
Dessert 12
-
$3.95
Cannoli
A mixture of sweetened ricotta and mascarpone cheeses in a baked crispy cinnamon shell sprinkled with chocolate chips and powdered sugar.
-
$4.90
Cheesecake
Creamy NY style cheesecake topped with your choice of cherries or drizzled chocolate sauce.
-
$2.75
Cookie
-
$5.25
Specialty Brownie
-
$5.50
Bundt Cake
-
$5.75
Specialty Dessert
-
$5.75
Yogurt Parfaits
-
$5.25
Strawberry Parfaits
-
$4.95
Brownie
-
$4.95
Specialty bar
-
$4.95
Pineapple upside down
-
$5.75
Specialty Dessert
Beverages 3
-
$3.25
Tea
-
$3.25
Pop
Coke - Diet Coke - Sprite - Root Beer - Mt. Dew - Orange - Dr. Pepper
-
$2.20
Coffee
Appetizers 18
-
$5.95
Cheese Sticks
-
$4.75
Jalapeño Chz Balls
-
$7.75
Jalapeño Poppers
-
$5.65
Fried Mushrooms
-
$6.65
Pizza Logs
-
$4.95
Zucchini Fries
-
$5.65
Onion Rings
-
$6.85
Jalapeño Shrimp Jammers
-
$5.65
Frd Banana Pepper Rings
-
$6.85
Fried Pickles Half lb.
-
$6.45
Veggie Basket
-
$7.50
Loaded Fries
-
Fries
traditional, waffle, cajun, buffalo, or sweet potato side
-
$6.85
Gouda Mac n Chz Bites
-
Garlic Bread
-
$5.65
Mini Tacos
-
$10.90
Nacho Pizza Sticks
12" pizza dough rolled thin with garlic-butter base, cheddar, tomatoes, and jalapeños, cut into sticks
-
$9.50
Pepperoni Balls
takes a little time, but worth the wait! (4)
Sandwiches 14
-
$7.40
Hamburger
-
$8.90
Chzburger
-
$9.95
Mushroom Burger
with Cheese
-
$9.95
The Castaway Burger
Our 6 oz. burger topped with fried salami, cheese, onion, lettuce, tomato, house dressing and mayo
-
$13.95
Famous Whimpy
1 lb. burger topped with lettuce, onion, pickles, 2 cheeses and our own "special" sauce
-
$11.95
Perch Sandwich
-
$9.95
Cod Sandwich
-
$11.75
Reuben
on Marble Rye
-
$10.45
Buffalo Ckn Sandwich
Our hand breaded chicken tossed in buffalo wing sauce. Served with choice of ranch or blue cheese
-
$9.95
Grilled Ckn Sandwich
-
$9.95
Breaded Ckn Sandwich
-
$12.95
Frisco Melt
1/2 lb. burger with sautéed onions, tomatoes and 1000 Island dressing
-
$12.45
Turkey Bacon Melt
-
$12.45
Ckn Tender Bacon Melt
with tomato
Dinners 8
-
$14.75
3pc Ckn Dinner
-
$14.95
Grilled Ckn Dinner
-
$13.95
Meatloaf Dinner
-
$19.50
Perch Dinner
-
$15.40
Cod Dinner
-
$14.95
Coconut Shrimp Dinner
-
$14.95
Butterfly Shrimp Dinner
-
$25.95
Captain's Feast Dinner
1 crab cake, 3 butterflied shrimp, 3 shrimp jammers, 3 pieces of perch and scallops
Salad 11
-
Antipasto
-
$11.45
Taco Salad
-
$11.45
Grilled Stk Salad
topped with fries
-
$11.45
Grilled Ckn Salad
topped with fries
-
$11.45
Crispy Ckn Salad
-
Buffalo Ckn Salad
Choose crispy or grilled chicken topped with fries
-
Tossed Salad
-
$12.45
Ckn Cobb Salad
Greens, bleu cheese crumble, egg, tomato, bacon, grilled chicken, and bacon dressing
-
$12.45
Orchard Ckn Salad
Greens, dried cranberries, apple, feta cheese, candied pecans, bacon, grilled chicken, grape vinaigrette
-
$12.45
Southwest Ckn Salad
Greens, jalapeño corn, cheddar, tortilla strips, black beans, grilled chicken, jalapeño ranch
-
$12.45
Mandarin Ckn Salad
Greens, mandarin oranges, carrot and cabbage mix, feta cheese, sunflower seeds, crispy chicken, and mandarin dressing
Pasta 3
-
Spaghetti n Meatballs
-
$15.95
Ckn Parm
-
$14.95
Eggplant Parm
Baskets 5
-
$15.95
10pc Trad Wing Basket
traditional wings
-
$12.75
10pc Boneless Wing Basket
-
$12.75
Ckn Tender Basket
-
$12.75
Shrimp Basket
-
$15.50
Perch Basket
Submarine Sandwiches 11
-
Godfather
What we are known for! This king of subs comes with ham, salami, pepperoni, onions, tomatoes, and provolone cheese toasted to perfection.
-
$15.95
The Admiral
-
$11.75
Meatball Submarine Sandwich
-
$11.95
Philly Ckn Submarine Sandwich
-
$11.95
Philly Stk Submarine Sandwich
-
$10.95
Pizza Sub
-
$10.95
Eggplant Submarine Sandwich
-
$10.95
Vegetarian Submarine Sandwich
-
$11.75
Buff Ckn Submarine Sandwich
-
$11.75
Ckn Parm Submarine Sandwich
-
$10.95
Ham n Chz Submarine Sandwich
Kids Menu 6
-
$7.95
K - 4 inch Sub
choose pizza, meatball, or ham and cheese
-
$7.95
K - Slice of Pizza
choose cheese or pepperoni
-
$7.95
K - Spaghetti
-
$7.95
K - Mac n Chz
-
$7.95
K - 6 piece Boneless Ckn
-
$7.95
K - Grilled Chz Sandwich
Monday Special 4
-
$11.00
M.S - 1 Topp Calzone
-
$11.95
M.S - Rodeo Burger with fries
-
$11.95
M.S - Barnyard Burger with fries
-
$12.00
M.S - 12" BBQ Chicken pizza
Tuesday Special 5
-
$12.00
T.S - 8" Philly with fries
-
$11.00
T.S - Taco Salad
-
$11.00
T.S - 1 Topp Stromboli
-
$12.00
T.S - 12" Terry's pizza
-
$12.00
T.S - 12" Taco Pizza
Wednesday Special 2
-
$10.00
W.S - Spaghetti Dinner
-
$7.00
W.S - 12" 1 Topping Pizza
Thursday Special 3
-
Th.S - Wings
-
$10.95
Th.S - 8" Godfather with tossed salad
-
$12.25
Th.S - 12" 2 Topp Stromboli
Friday Special 4
-
$9.95
F.S - Small Antipasto Salad and 2 breadsticks
-
$20.00
F.S - Cheese Sheet Pizza
-
$24.00
F.S - 1 topping sheet pizza
-
$12.95
F.S - Perch Sandwich and Fries
Saturday Special 6
-
$15.00
Sat.S - 18" 1 topping pizza
-
$34.18
Sat.S - 18" 1 topping pizza 12 wings and a 2 liter
-
$13.95
Sat.S - 18" 1 topping pizza
-
$13.95
Sat.S - Cod Dinner
-
$11.00
Sat.S - Steak Salad
-
$11.00
Sat.S - Chicken Salad
Sunday Special 3
-
$11.95
S.S - Reuben with fries
-
$10.95
S.S - Mushroom Burger with fries
-
$25.00
S.S - 12" 2 topping pizza and 10 wings
Soups 2
-
Shrimp n Corn Chowder
Ask About Our Featured Soup
-
Soup of the Day
Stromboli 3
-
Cheese Stromboli
-
$11.15
Gluten Free Stromboli
-
$11.15
Cauliflower Stromboli
Calzone 3
-
Cheese Calzone
-
$11.15
Gluten Free Calzone
-
$11.15
Cauliflower Calzone
Specials 45
-
$12.95
Sausage and Pepper
-
$12.95
Cabbage Roll Dinner
-
$12.95
12" Reuben Stromboli
-
$12.95
Black n Bleu Burger with fries
-
$12.95
Capone Burger and Fries
-
$11.50
Chicken Bacon Swiss Sandwich with fries
-
$9.95
Chicken Mash Bowl
-
$12.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch
-
$12.95
Clam Dinner
-
$10.95
Cream Chicken over Biscuits
-
$12.95
Fish
-
$11.50
Fish Tacos w HM chips n salsa
-
$10.95
Goulash
-
$12.95
Greatlakes Burger with Fries
-
$11.95
Gyro with fries
-
$11.95
Lasagna Dinner
-
$12.95
Meatloaf Melt with fries
-
$12.95
Philly Burger with fries
-
$12.95
Pot Roast Melt with fries
-
$11.95
Red Rooster with fries
-
$10.95
Open Face Turkey
-
$10.95
Open Face Pot Roast
-
$10.50
Grilled Cheese with bowl of soup
-
$12.95
Stuffed Pepper Dinner
-
$12.95
Country Fried Steak
-
$8.95
Soup Bread Bowl
-
$11.95
Pasta Bowl with side
-
$13.95
Ribeye melt with fries
-
$10.95
Cream Chip Beef
-
$14.25
Honey Breaded Flounder dinner
-
$12.95
12" Cheeseburger Pizza
-
$12.95
12" The Vincinia Stromboli
-
$11.95
Croissant Club with fries
-
$12.95
Cod Tender basket
-
$9.75
Pot Pie with a side
-
$12.95
Chicken Swiss Melt with Fries
-
$12.95
12" Sausage n Pepper Stromboli
-
$10.95
Cabbage n Noodles
-
$13.95
Wagyu Burger with Fries
-
$10.95
Pickle Chicken Sandwich with fries
-
$11.95
Kielbasa Sub with fries
-
$9.95
Loaded Nachos
-
$9.95
Loaded Nachos
-
$7.50
Bruschetta
-
$9.25
Chorizo Dip
Ready to order from Castaways?
You finish the order on the restaurant’s own site, so nothing you pay is skimmed by a delivery app — and no marketplace commission comes out of it.