Pizza restaurants in Middletown, NY

5 kitchens in Middletown that sell online themselves. The order lands with the restaurant, not a delivery app.

All of Middletown
Breakfast & Brunch1
Mexican1
Restaurant1
Sandwiches & Deli1

Best rated first

1–5 of 5

Cuisine is worked out from each restaurant’s own name and menu, so a kitchen that cooks two things lands under one of them.

Frank's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Pizza in Middletown, NY

4.4 (1,100)461 items

Pellegrino & Son's Pizzeria

Pizza in Middletown, NY

4.4 (334)455 items

Three Brothers Pizza

Pizza in Middletown, NY

4.3 (190)357 items

Badabing Pizzeria

Pizza in Middletown, NY

4.2 (407)387 items

Johnâ€™s of Arthur Ave Restaurant and Pizzeria

Pizza in Middletown, NY

99 items

Pizza in other cities

Every Pizza kitchen

Bethlehem, PA2
Columbus, OH2
Hackettstown, NJ2
Norcross, GA2
Amenia, NY1
Ashland, MA1
Charlotte, NC1
Cold Spring, NY1
Doraville, GA1
Doylestown, PA1
Easton, PA1
Ellenville, NY1

Same kitchen. No markup.

DoorDash and Uber Eats publish delivery commissions of 15–30% per order, and charge you again at checkout. Everything listed here takes the order on its own site instead, so the price you see is the restaurant’s own.

Browse by city